Paul which is the commandment to love and as Fletcher is a Christian as is JAT Robinson it shows that doing the most loving thing won't cause any harm as love is harmless and looks for the best interests in every human. In the other hand, a weakness of SE is that love and justice are not the same as love searches for not what people deserve put more on what people need and justice is what people deserve and therefore it makes it difficult to calculate how to serve love justly.
In conclusion, ultimately the weaknesses outweigh the strengths because situation ethics' biggest challenge is that important rules and laws that have been applied in order to make society safe can be broken e. The state of each country has set up certain rules in order to have justice served, in the UK if you murder someone you face the charges that the law has given and if important rules like do not murder are broken this results in a unjust society and extremely dangerous society.
Leave a Reply
If love is the only rule then there is a huge loss in protection. Posted from TSR Mobile. Badges: 9. Report 5 years ago 2. Hi there, While you're waiting for an answer, did you know we have , study resources that could answer your question in TSR's Learn together section? Take a look around. If you're stuck on how to get started, try creating some resources.
Cookies on the BBC website
It's free to do and can help breakdown tough topics into manageable chunks. Get creating now. Not sure what all of this is about? Head here to find out more. Quick Reply. Submit reply. Attached files. Write a reply Back to top. Related discussions. Related articles.
- english department creative writing harvard.
- Situation ethics!
- thesis statement activity esl.
- quote paragraph in essay.
- Theory Description: Situation Ethics Theory Research Paper;
- Religious Studies;
Related university courses. My Feed. Oops, nobody has posted in the last few hours. Why not re-start the conversation? Oops, nobody is replying to posts. Why not reply to an un-answered thread? Today on TSR. Thinking of dropping out? What to do if you're not sure uni is right for you.
University open days. University of Bristol. Undergraduate Open Afternoon Undergraduate. Wed, 23 Oct ' University of Exeter. University of Nottingham. Mini Open Day Undergraduate. Poll Join the discussion. Yes I know where I'm applying. No I haven't decided yet. Yes but I might change my mind. Yes I know where I'm applying No I haven't decided yet Yes but I might change my mind Watched Threads View All.
Words: , Paragraphs: 30, Pages: 5. Situation ethics is an alternative ethical theory, particularly influential in Protestant Christianity, similar to utilitarianism, in that it is a way a deciding upon the correct action that is to be taken in a given situation, but where happiness has been substituted for love. It does however take an individualistic approach, with the emphasis being upon each person, rather than on looking after the majority, as is the case in utilitarianism.
The theory is based on love, and revolves around doing the most loving thing for the greatest number of people.
- introduction for communication essay.
- writing my dissertation proposal!
- music business internship cover letter;
- henry ford essay the first assembly line.
- Situation ethics.
It is teleological which means that is consequential and not based on rules. An American professor of ethics, Fletcher developed Situation ethics as a result of his critique of Legalism and Antinomianism.
Fletcher disliked like the way in which so many ethical theories, such as utilitarianism, were based upon and around a basic set of rules; that is to say, that they take a legalistic approach. He believed that this was too rigid, and that it did not allow for exceptions. He circulated this theory in the s, having used his beliefs and concerns to come up with, what he believed, was a fair way of deciding what the right action to take in a situation should be. He believed that something could be determined as good or evil, depending on whether or not love had been fully served.
Relativism — there are no fixed rules that must be obeyed, but all decisions must be relative to Christian love. Positivism — this can be divided into two categories; natural positivism, where reason deduces faith from natural phenomena or human experience, and theological positivism, where reason works within faith as opposed to being the basis for faith. Though religious knowledge or belief can be approached in either way, people must understand that love is the most important thing. Personalism — situationists put people first, asking what to do to best help them, instead of putting laws first as a legalist would do.
Ethics sample answer from exam - Religious Studies Tutor Brighton - RCR Tuition : RCR Tuition
Value is only added to something when it is useful to love working for the sake of persons. Love is the only thing that is good in itself, and is good in all situations. You are only required to follow laws, rules and regulations if they serve love, therefore it replaces, and cannot be equalled by, any other law. Good actions should not be done for reward, but for their own sake. Love and justice cannot be serperated from each other, as justice is love at work for the whole community.
Now you could just talk about ethical dilemmas in general and whether Utilitarianism or Kant is more useful. However I think you run the risk of producing a vague and bland answer.
Situation Ethics Essay
I would stick with the dilemmas surrounding Business Ethics this is what your examiners are really looking for. So before you start writing decide which dilemmas or issues you are going to talk about e. This is an example of what I would class as a good introduction. Always a sign of a good start! When answering a question that specifies two theories Util and Kant in this case then you need to decide your four paragraph rule for each — this is your structure.
Skip to content. Like this: Like Loading